a 01-05 civic manual would be great (avoid the time bomb auto trans) or a 03+ corolla stick (with high miles tho) i see them on craigslist for a tad bit over 5000, but after negotiating you can bring it to around 5.
your criteria and mines are almost the same, mines is
150k or under
japanese (honda or toyota)
stick has to average over 30 mpg, auto over 28
rounded shape (not a box)
$5000 or less
has at least dual airbags
4 cylinder
1.9 liters or under
little rust/sun damage
seats 5
i'm really towards japanese cars, its just that i had really bad experiences with domestic cars. im not hating on domestics though
__________________