Quote:
Originally Posted by 95metro
Serious testing takes time and energy.
... a dyno, This would remove most of the variables that on-road tests are generally prone to.
On-road tests with some form of data collection (ie - ScanGauge, SuperMID, data acquisition computer/software) are always at the mercy of the elements. Temperature, humidity, wind, and (most of all) the driver are variables that cannot be determined as to their affects on a given test.
However, a calm, warm day and a relatively flat road (or predetermined "track") will provide some data to at least make educated assumptions on.
Weather and track conditions must be recorded before each run.... to establish a baseline and/or margin of error between runs. I personally feel that multiple runs are necessary since environment and driving style could cause fluctuations in fuel economy during each run.
... the test should be performed again on a different day. Different vehicles and testing on different days would ensure that the device is indeed causing an improvement in mileage. If it really does work we should see slight to obvious results every time the device is added regardless of vehicle or environment.
|
Generally, a good synopsis of testing procedures. However, I feel the need to say a few things....
1) "...takes time and energy." You forgot money! Bring lots! After all, "you get what you pay for." Scotch tape, wire, and generalizations don't cut it!
2) "...a dyno." Again, bring money...especially if considering buy one!
Dynos are not "real world"! They do provide absolute deltas, though. Two areas where dynos are useless...weight and wind effects. These are "real world" parameters!
3) 'Mercy of the elements".... Good point! Temp., BP, & RH can be monitored, wind direction can be ignored if steady and slight. Dyno correction factors require changing HP results according to a standardized chart...to put all / everyone "on the same page".
4) Multiple runs will average out the variables ; long runs are better than short.
5) Different vehicles? ...on different days? Why? A good, solid delta can be "translated" to any vehicle, anyplace! The delta may not be constant, but better is better!
__________________