Quote:
Originally Posted by trollbait
China isn't drilling off the US coast.
http://www.mcclatchydc.com/251/story/40994.html
Cleanly is a realtive term in oil extraction. Getting the crude from the Canadian tar sands results in contaminated water held in man made lakes. The shale oil will require more water to refine thasn the tar sands.
There will come a time when oil is worth more for what can made from it, than for burning it. Better to save domestic reserves for that time.
|
China probably backtracked their plan. Chinese rigs have been spotted in that area before, it wouldn't be hard for them to remove them quickly:
Cuba, China Drilling for Oil 50 Miles from Florida Shores
House bill aims to end U.S. moratorium in waters twice as far from shore
Written By: James M. Taylor
Published In: Environment News
Publication Date: August 1, 2006
Publisher: The Heartland Institute
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Legislation to relax restrictions on offshore oil and gas recovery passed the U.S. House of Representatives Resources Committee on June 21 by a vote of 29-9.
House Resolution 4761, with more than 160 co-sponsors, gained significant attention after Cuba announced it would expand its leasing of oil and natural gas for Chinese drilling within 50 miles of the Florida Keys.
The House legislation would end all federal moratoria on resource recovery more than 100 miles from U.S. shores. Individual states would have the option of allowing recovery between 50 and 100 miles from their shores.
Currently, there is no blanket federal prohibition on resource recovery more than 100 miles from shore, but there are patchwork prohibitions established on a case-by-case basis. There is currently a blanket moratorium on resource recovery less than 100 miles from shore. These restrictions amount to a self-imposed moratorium on 85 percent of the nation's offshore oil reserves.
China Drilling Near Florida
The presence of Chinese oil rigs, there by agreement with Cuba, within view of the Florida coastline has irked state residents. Cuba has announced it will expand those operations.
"I saw all kinds of wells with Chinese writing on them just south of the Keys," Leonard Gropper, a Marathon, Florida retiree, told the June 20 Orlando Sun-Sentinel.
With just 90 miles separating Cuba and the Florida Keys, Cuba has legal rights to oil and natural gas reserves in its half of the Florida Strait. Cuba can, therefore, produce or lease for production oil and natural gas reserves as close as 45 miles from U.S. shores.
"China is trying to lock up resources around the world, and they are locking up resources in our own backyard where we can't even compete and play ball," Sen. Larry Craig (R-ID) told the Sun-Sentinel. "This is simply wrong. I've had enough, and I believe the American people have had enough."
Needs Are Changing
The U.S. moratorium was imposed during the 1990s when oil prices were low and the need for new production seemed distant. Those days are long gone, observes Heritage Foundation Senior Policy Analyst Ben Lieberman.
"While fears of environmental damage trumped price concerns in the 1990s, times have changed. Technological advances have greatly reduced environmental risks, and oil prices are much higher now and do not appear likely to appreciably decline any time soon," said Lieberman.
"The changing nature of the situation is being driven home very starkly with the [construction] of Chinese oil rigs within sight of U.S. shores," Lieberman added. "The Chinese can drill within sight of our coastline, but we cannot. In fact, we cannot drill even twice as far away from the U.S. coastline as the Chinese do. This does not sit well with many people in Florida."
http://www.heartland.org/Article.cfm?artId=19479
==================================================
it does not mean that they will not resume operations there. as far as "cleanly" as a relative term, yes it sure is relative.
tar sands oil will destory the area they are being mined at...that's Canada's choice to harvest oil from it.
as far as shale oil using more water in order to refine it, that depends on how the shale oil will be processed. mining the shale is not a good option, Shell's plan to heat the ground to release the oil is a better alternative and IT IS CLEANER compared to Exxon's old process of mining the shales and using steam to release the oil.
it's still a better alternative than to send dollars overseas for oil and fund terrorists. I do agree that there will come a time where oil would be too costly to burn, I don't see that time coming anytime soon. again, there is no single alternative that can replaced oil. so the status quo is still being pushed to be kept in place - buy oil from foreign countries instead of keeping oil profits locally and use part of the profits to fund alternative fuel research.
__________________