Today I had similar issue.
I had a partial fuel-up.
Previously to adding it to Fuelly, I had a 11.3L/100km average, which is rather correct.
I added a Partial fuel-up for 5 liters, and now my average is 5,7L/100 km, which is way off.
I did select Partial Fuel-Up checkbox.
Mazda 3 (Mazda 3) | Fuelly
Did I do something wrong, or it calculates as expected?
I thought that entering a Partial Fuel-Up won't change the Average L/100Km value until next full fuel-up.