That's expected, because once you mark a fuel-up as partial we need a full tank again to be able to calculate an MPG for an individual fuel-up. Fuelly works by calculating the
difference from full, so without that full tank there's no way to get an MPG for an individual fuel-up. There's more info
here and
here. So the rule to keep in mind is that if you mark a tank a partial, you won't get an individual MPG rating for that tank
or the next tank even if that next tank is full.
Keep in mind that all fuel-ups still contribute to your overall average MPG even if there is no individual MPG rating for a particular fuel-up.
__________________