Did you set up your car for Odo or Trip miles?
If on Odo, then you enter the odo reading + fuel (however note that the fuel used is irrelevant for this first tank since it can only work out miles when the second tank figures are entered).
If on Trip, then you reset the trip meter each time you fill up, but record the miles + fuel used. <-- This is the way I personally prefer.
__________________
|